Category Archives: Pensions

Stoneport releases its ESG Ambitions Statement to offer smaller DB schemes an affordable way to manage ESG integration

Stoneport, the UK consolidator for small defined benefit (DB) schemes, is delighted to announce the publication of its ESG Ambitions Statement, which includes its ESG (Environmental, Social and Governance) and stewardship policy.

Stuart Southall, Chair of Trustees of Stoneport commented, “ESG investing has become increasingly important for pension schemes. Last year, research from River and Mercantile[i] found that the vast majority (98 per cent) of DB pension scheme trustees viewed environmental, social and governance (ESG) integration as a pressing priority for the year ahead.”

“However, there are challenges for smaller DB schemes developing their own ESG policies – they are costly to put in place, hard to manage administratively which means that some schemes will be deterred from embedding ESG in their reporting and creating policies ahead of any future regulation.”

Stoneport’s solution is to run one ESG policy for all members that join its consolidator scheme. All the costs, governance and reporting requirements are taken care of by trustees at Stoneport and employers, sponsors and trustees in the scheme will be able to communicate their ESG credentials to their members at a much lower cost than if they were to go it alone.

Discussing ESG, Southall says, “When schemes look at ESG – most focus on the E first – the environment issues, which is important. A good example of this being Luton Council recently voting for its pension fund to disinvest £40m from fossil fuel firms.. However, the social and governance are equally as important.”

Stoneport says that while social can be difficult to quantify, schemes have an obligation to understand how the companies they invest in approach social responsibility and treat their people. How well these companies are governed is a critical consideration too, as research shows good governance can enhance the profitability of companies and improve asset returns for members.

Southall adds, “By running one ESG policy for all members who join our scheme, smaller schemes don’t have to lose out and can demonstrate their commitment to ESG to their members.”

The ESG policy is another milestone for Stoneport, who last week appointed Mobius Life Ltd as their investment platform provider. The company also recently announced the publication of its DB Master Trust Self-Certificate, part of a ground-breaking initiative set in train by the DWP and supported by the Pensions and Lifetime Savings Association.

For more information visit: www.stoneport.co.uk

[i] https://www.pensionsage.com/pa/ESG-integration-a-pressing-priority-for-DB-schemes-in-2021.php

Has sustainable credit reached a tipping point to catch up with sustainable investing?

As UK pension schemes are under increasing pressure to make greener investments, and insurers are urged to consider their exposure to climate risks and build resilience, CAMRADATA’s latest whitepaper, Sustainable Credit asks if the asset class has reached a tipping point.

The whitepaper includes insight from firms including Breckinridge Capital Advisors, Morgan Stanley Investment Management, TwentyFour Asset Management, Cambridge Associates, Redington, Law Debenture and Willis Towers Watson who attended a virtual roundtable hosted by CAMRADATA in October.

The report highlights that it’s about time the bond market saw greater innovation in sustainable finance, as pension schemes and insurance companies have a great need for bonds, whether to balance their liabilities, or in the case of high yield credits, even to try and achieve growth.

Also, as UK pension schemes have long been encouraged to go green, now it’s the turn of the insurance sector, with the International Association of Insurance Supervisors urging insurers to consider their exposure to climate risks (principally from climate-related insurance claims) and build resilience.

Natasha Silva, Managing Director, Client Relations, CAMRADATA said, “This year NEST – a government-created UK pension fund – converted an existing $2 billion allocation with a bond manager to a climate-transition global investment-grade credit strategy. More evidence that a tipping point for sustainable credit could have arrived came recently, when the UK government announced plans to issue its first green gilt.

“A number of other European countries have taken similar steps. This is significant because sovereign issuance is seen by some fund managers as a prerequisite for galvanising corporates of the same nation to become bold enough to issue their own sustainable corporate bonds.

“Our panel discussed developments in sustainable credit by fund managers, the level of demand among investors, and to what extent the market is catching up with sustainable investing – making this whitepaper an essential read for investors and fund managers alike.”

The asset managers at the event discussed how they integrate Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG) issues into their portfolio management process and organisation, before the panel was asked when sustainability was a matter of values and when is it part of an investment case.

They then tackled the question of whether academic research or industry analysis justified the prospects for sustainable investing, before considering whether there was better value for sustainable credit in High Yield (HY) or Investment Grade (IG).

The final topic was diversification in asset management and the growing need for the finance industry to do more work on diversity, equity and inclusion (DE&I) to encourage the young generation to look at careers in asset management.

 

Key takeaway points were:

 

  • One asset manager said they don’t have a separate ESG team so the integration of all material issues is handled by the portfolio managers and analysts. Another said that ESG is integrated across strategies, but is also a management tool, adding “ESG adds rigour, that materiality gets backed into business operations.”

 

  • A consultant said there were times when carbon targets may be in conflict with fiduciary responsibility, but there was enough noise about Climate Change that if you position the portfolio to mitigate carbon risk, you are likely acting in keeping with your fiduciary responsibility.

 

  • On the intersection between values and investment imperatives, one consultant said it came down to clients’ beliefs. Some are very clear what they are looking for, with some demanding 2035 net-zero carbon targets, but added that it was quite hard to find managers striking the balance between returns and climate change objectives.

 

  • Another consultant said fixed income managers have always considered ESG, particularly G. With respect to E and S, they spoke to a mining analyst five years ago, who said they didn’t do ESG. When asked what kept him up at night, he said toxic spills and labour relations. He was doing ESG; he just didn’t call it that.

 

  • On green bonds, one panellist felt there were challenges still to be addressed, notably where use of proceeds has been poorly communicated or too vague and not audited.

 

  • Another shared some reservations, giving an example of a utility’s sustainability-linked bond where the step-up in coupon was too close to the maturity to be a meaningful motivation.

 

  • But they noted that eight months later the same issuer came to the market with a much longer period between trigger date and maturity, highlighting this was a case of the issuer listening to the market.

 

  • Turning to diversification in asset management it was suggested that when it comes to the social factors related to diversity, equity and inclusion (DE&I): these are already more front of-mind in the US than in Europe.

 

  • Another said the social tragedies that took place in the US in 2020 certainly escalated diversity, equity, and inclusion higher up on the agenda for most companies, adding when looking for diversity, the talent pool in asset management is not as big as it could be.

 

  • For another, diversity today feels as if it is where ESG was five years ago. They stressed the importance of also considering cognitive diversity rather than identity characteristics when it comes to the manager research process, as more diverse teams make better decisions.

 

  • A final comment from a consultant was that they agreed wholeheartedly on cognitive diversity for improving board efficiency, concluding the session with a final point “there is a moral aspect here too, as well as the board efficiency argument – we need to get away from discrimination and considering protected characteristics are important to give everyone opportunities.”

 

 

To download the ‘Sustainable Credit’ whitepaper click here.

For more information on CAMRADATA visit www.camradata.com

No plan for the future: Most Brits have no clue about pension payments and two in five can’t even find their savings

The working population of Britain is woefully underprepared for retirement, with the majority unaware of what payments they’re entitled to or how to access their funds, according to new research.

The money.co.uk study investigated Brits’ understanding of pensions, finding that four in five don’t know what weekly payments they’ll receive during retirement, while a further 13% didn’t realise they were entitled to anything at all.

Perhaps more alarmingly, almost a quarter of respondents (24%) admitted they’d struggle to locate and access their pension pots, with another 18% stating they had “no idea” whatsoever.

The study also asked how Brits were planning to finance their future, aside from working one regular job, and traditional methods such as making use of savings accounts (38%) and investing in stocks and shares (15%) were most popular.

But as many as one in 10 said they plan to – or already do – work a second job to help in later life.

 

How Brits aim to make money to help plan for the future, outside of a main job:

 

Method Percentage
Putting money in a savings account 38.4%
Investing in stocks/shares 15.2%
Investing in property 11.5%
Awaiting an inheritance 10.3%
Second job 10.1%
Premium bonds 9.3%
Foreign exchange trading 2.7%

 

But, with the ever-increasing cost of living putting a strain on the younger generation, it seems as though the 16-24-year-olds and 25-34-year-olds are putting away a higher proportion of their earnings for the future than those aged 35-54. With the over-55s edging closer to retirement age, this proportion then jumps back up again as they approach the end of their careers.

 

How pension contributions vary with age:

 

Age range Average proportion of salary put into pension pots each month
16-24 8.1%
25-34 7.2%
35-44 6.4%
45-54 6.9%
55+ 8.2%

 

Salman Haqqi, Personal Finance Editor at money.co.uk said: “A pension is a vitally important tool for helping provide a stable income in later life. Once people retire, this often forms the majority of their income, so the nine in 10 people who were unsure about their future may want to re-familiarise themselves with the systems, as well as the location of their pension pots and log in details, to avoid any potential issues that could arise in the future.

“The basic state pension payment is £137.60 per week, with this amount rising to £179.60 for younger workers, as outlined on the government’s website. However, 25% of Brits are missing out on potential further payments in the future as they have opted out from additional personal or workplace pensions. It is certainly worth assessing your options to provide the right balance between having enough disposable income now, and ensuring financial security in the future.”

 

Budget brings welcome changes for pensions, says Pensions Expert

A Budget intended to help drive economic growth as we recover from Coronavirus also brought some welcome changes for the pensions world, says a Quantum Advisory expert.

Pension tax top-ups for low earners

The Government will develop a solution to the ‘net pay anomaly’ where some low earners can miss out on tax relief if they pay pension contributions through a ‘Net Pay’ arrangement.  From 2025/26 a system will be put in place that provides top-ups to affected individuals to broadly give the same outcome as if they paid contributions through a ‘Relief at Source’ arrangement.

The system will apply to pension contributions made from 2024/25 onwards.  The Government calculates the average benefit for affected individuals to be £53 per year.

Simon Hubbard, a Senior Consultant and Actuary at Quantum Advisory, said: “Industry commentators have been asking the Government for years now to resolve the unfair tax treatment of pension contributions by low-paid workers.  This change will be welcomed by many, though it’s disappointing that it will not apply until April 2024. However, the bigger question of increasing the auto enrolment minimum contribution amounts has been avoided for a further year.”

Changes to the charge cap on defined contribution (DC) pensions

The Government will consult on how the 0.75% pa cap on DC pension scheme charges can be adapted to allow for well-designed investment performance fees.  The cap currently prevents the default investment strategy from using funds with a performance-related fee because it could exceed the cap if performance is strong.

Social Housing Pension Scheme: 50% contribution rise could make them unaffordable

Message from Quantum Advisory at the Community Housing Cymru Virtual Finance Conference

LEADING independent pension expert Quantum Advisory has addressed attendees at the Community Housing Cymru (CMC) Virtual Finance Conference about the implications for housing associations resulting from the 2020 Social Housing Pension Scheme (SHPS) valuation results. Actuaries Stuart Price and Adam Cottrell spoke candidly during the Pensions Update workshop about the net increase in contribution rates for SHPS members and the possible implications in the future.

The CMC Virtual Finance Conference was held over two days (7-8 October) and covered a host of topics currently affecting housing associations including the repercussions of the pandemic. Alongside Quantum Advisory, speakers included former footballer Fabrice Muamba and representatives from the Welsh Government, BBC Wales and #Housing2030.

Quantum Advisory spoke to delegates about issues surrounding the SHPS 30 September 2020 valuation results which, although showed a positive investment performance of assets and increasing deficit contributions from employers, also highlighted the limited growth potential due to de-risked investments and hedging protection.

The employee benefit specialists also looked to the future of such schemes and the increasing costs. Stuart Price said: “The 2020 valuation shows a 50% increase in contribution rates for future service which might simply make it unaffordable for many employees. Employers have a few options going forward. They can either share the increase with employees, change the defined benefit sections offered to employees or decide to close the defined benefit scheme altogether. No real easy decisions for employers and it will be interesting to see what they decide to do.”

Quantum Advisory, which has its headquarters in Cardiff, provides a full suite of pensions services to employers and trustees. For further information visit www.quantumadvisory.co.uk.

 

National Pension Tracing Day Could Reunite People with £19billion of Lost Pensions

THE pension industry is rallying together for the UK’s first ever National Pension Tracing Day which aims to identify owners of more than 1.6million lost or forgotten pension pots worth approximately £19.4billion.

National Pension Tracing Day takes place on 31 October 2021 to coincide with the clocks going back and encourages people to utilise the extra hour to search for pensions they might not know exist. The Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) predicts there could be up to 50million lost pensions by 2050 if nothing is done to try and reunite owners with their retirement funds.

Partner and Actuary at Quantum Advisory, Stuart Price, commends the new initiative. Stuart said: “So many people change job without notifying their pension providers and the pension is forgotten about.

“It’s estimated that nearly £20billion is lying idle in pension pots that no-one knows about which is a staggering amount of money sat waiting to be claimed. People should use this day to visit the dedicated online resource centre run by the government, which is so easy to use and get the ball rolling”

National Pension Tracing Day was founded by Punter Southall Aspire, with backing from Scottish Widows, Aegon, Legal & General and Standard Life. People are encouraged to take a moment on the day the clocks go back to initiate tracing lost pensions. The government runs a Pension Tracing Website with helpful information about the process. Visit https://www.gov.uk/find-pension-contact-details.

For details about pensions and employee benefits, visit: www.quantumadvisory.co.uk.

Regulation, Regulation, Regulation … is it all getting too much?

Mounting regulatory requirements for DB pension schemes are taking their toll on many skilled professional trustees and even driving them out of their roles. But if it’s too much for the professional trustees, what does this mean for lay trustees of small schemes?

New research from Charles Stanley Fiduciary Management amongst professional trustees of UK defined benefit pension schemes found that two-thirds (62%) are finding regulations too burdensome and overly complex and so are planning to step down from their role within the next three years – many far sooner.

The survey revealed that 44% said they didn’t have the right knowledge for the job, 41% said the reporting requirements were too onerous and 24% said the role was taking up too much time.

Clearly a reduction of professional trustees available in the market could have a damaging effect on the potential stability and success of schemes, but this report also highlights another worry.

According to the Pensions Regulator, the number of pure defined benefit schemes with professional trustees on their boards stood at 1,538 out of 4,797 in 2020/21, which leaves over 3,200 schemes run by non-professionals, often a scheme member, finance director or company owner.  Most professional trustees work for the largest schemes, and so it is the lay trustees that run the smaller end of the market.

Whilst this group of amazing people do a great job, if professional trustees of large schemes are struggling, the key question becomes how are trustees of smaller schemes coping?

Some of the trustees of smaller pension schemes we speak to have been trustees for 20 years, some have worked for the company running the scheme – they are emotionally invested in their schemes and don’t want to walk away, but clearly now is the time to seek a new type of support as an option for their schemes.

This is where Stoneport can help. The Stoneport Pension Scheme was set up last year to consolidate small schemes and tackle the problems faced by smaller schemes head on.

Being part of Stoneport means that governance headaches and regulatory pressures are completely removed from trustees. However, that doesn’t mean that trustees no longer have to be involved in their schemes. Through the Stoneport Alliance, scheme representatives retain votes on all key decisions.

In addition to this, Stoneport’s unique, purpose-built structure enables it to achieve a significantly higher level of cost savings and improved member benefit security, by bringing different employers’ schemes together to run as it was a much larger and stronger scheme.

With Stoneport we are Stronger Together.

For more information contact joining@stoneport.com

ESG issues to be placed at the forefront of pension investments

LEADING independent pensions and employee benefit advisors Quantum Advisory has addressed the importance of placing environmental, social and government (ESG) considerations at the forefront of decisions to invest assets to ensure a sustainable future.

Investment consultant at Quantum, Stefano Carnevale, spoke during an hour-long webinar with ICAEW South, South West and Wales, focussing on ESG issues and opportunities for trustees of small to medium defined benefit pension schemes.

In light of pressing megatrends such as climate change, inequality, digitalisation and cybersecurity, Stefano said: “When considering sustainability and responsible investing, it’s often the case that most investors focus solely on environmental concerns, yet we must not ignore the social and governance impacts as all three facets of ESG play a role in creating a better future.

“Younger investors are driving trustees and pension providers to incorporate ESG into investment decisions which will generate positive, long-term returns. Luckily, ESG asset options are becoming more accessible through a rise in pooled products and investment vehicles, allowing for both passive and actively managed funds.”

In addition to commitments to align portfolios with metrics such as the Paris Agreement, trustees will also need to demonstrate ESG considerations through stricter reporting procedures.

To date, UK pension schemes are required to update their Statement of Investment Principles (SIP) to reflect the trustee’s policies on financially material considerations (including ESG), non-financial considerations, stewardship and governance requirements.

From this month (October 2021), UK pension schemes are required to produce an annual implementation statement to show how the policies reported in SIPs have been actioned.

Stefano said: “As the regulator becomes more heavily involved, trustees will need to show that they have effective governance to assess and manage ESG risks and opportunities. We would recommend that trustees familiarise themselves with the Taskforce for Climate-Related Financial Disclosure (TCFD) and their disclosures for governance, strategy, risk management, metrics and targets in readiness for future reporting practices.”

Quantum Advisory, which has five offices across the UK, including Amersham, Birmingham, Bristol, Cardiff and London, provides pension and employee benefits services to employers, scheme trustees and members. For more information about Quantum Advisory, please visit https://quantumadvisory.co.uk.

Rise to the challenge of engaging members with their DB Pensions says Stoneport

This Pensions Awareness Day, Stoneport is urging employers and trustees of Defined Benefit Pensions to rise to the challenge of educating and informing members about their schemes to drive better engagement.

Richard Jones, Managing Director, Stoneport says, “DB pension schemes were set up with a simple aim – to provide their members with an income in retirement for life – but in recent years they have become complex as the regulatory environment has shifted, and the economic and demographic landscape has evolved. The task employers and trustees face to educate and inform members has never been more challenging. Increasing life expectancy means that members rely on their DB pensions for longer, whilst low interest rates make DB pensions much more valuable. And, while pension freedoms provide increased flexibility, they have opened the door to pension scams.”

“The industry is however, responding well. By embracing technology and engaging with communications specialists, the way schemes engage with their members is being transformed for the better. According to research from Buck, member engagement rates increased to between 30% and 40% when members were provided with online, real-time access to their scheme benefits, compared to the industry average engagement rate of around 10%.”

Stoneport highlights that some schemes now provide an array of helpful services to their members. Some schemes have their own websites, providing members with:

  • Access to information on scheme benefits and the options they have about when and what form they can take their benefits in.
  • Important scheme documents like the scheme’s accounts, statement of investment principles and summary funding statement.
  • Scheme booklets and member guides, along with references to external sources of information and guidance.
  • Secure portals which provide online access to personal information and allow updates to be made – for example, amending nominations for death benefits.

Stoneport says leaders in Aerospace, Defence and Security, Leonardo S.p.A is a shining example of how much can be done with member engagement, providing three separate websites – one for its multi-award-winning DC offering, FuturePlanner, and one for each of its £1bn plus Electronics and Helicopters DB schemes. The DB sites even have an online modeller, allowing members to estimate their future pension at retirement, and to see the impact of retiring at different ages and taking different amounts of cash.

Large schemes like those operated by Leonardo can do this because they have the scale and resources to provide these things to their members in a cost-effective way. Unfortunately, that is not true of all. Whilst employers and trustees all want to do the best they can for their members, cost pressures often determine what is delivered in practice.

Currently around 80% of private sector DB schemes have fewer than 1,000 members and lack the scale to ever run efficiently and effectively – just meeting the ever-increasing compliance burden can lead to running costs exceeding £1,000 per member every year, compared to under £200 for the largest schemes.

Jones says, “As a result of cost pressures, members of many smaller DB schemes tend to receive just one communication a year. The only way for members to find out more or to engage with their benefits, is by writing to the scheme’s administrator and they want and deserve better support.”

A recent survey from Hymans Robertson found that 47 per cent of respondents would welcome more support on what options are available to them, with just 21 per cent believing that they already have an adequate level of support.

He adds, “With access to the right information and support, members will be better equipped to guard against pension scams and to make sound financial decisions for themselves. Stoneport aims to bring together 100 smaller DB schemes and then to leverage its scale and use technology to provide the ‘best in class’ member experience of a large DB scheme like one of Leonardo’s and radically reduce the running costs.”


About Stoneport

Stoneport is a consolidation vehicle for occupational defined benefit pension schemes in the UK with fewer than 1,000 members. It was conceived and developed by Punter Southall and will be managed by Stoneport Pensions Management Limited, a wholly owned subsidiary of Punter Southall. Barnett Waddingham will provide administration services plus the actuarial and investment advisory services required to operate Stoneport. Stoneport will be regulated by the Pensions Regulator, just like the small schemes it provides a solution for.

About Punter Southall

Punter Southall has been developing new ways to transform people’s financial future, since 1988. We help our clients to discover and seize the right opportunities. By listening to them and understanding their needs, we change and adapt our portfolio of companies and services to help deliver their goals. We work with pension schemes, employers, insurers, charities, and private clients to provide expertise in pensions and investments, wealth management, workplace savings, health and protection, and financial data.

 

Howden’s Three Wishes for Pensions Awareness Day 2021

To mark Pensions Awareness Day 2021 (15th September 2021) Howden Employee Benefits & Wellbeing shares its three wishes for driving better workplace pensions and member outcomes: data-driven governance, greener pensions, and better financial education.

Matthew Gregson, Executive Director at Howden said, “Pensions are the single biggest investment many employees will ever make; however, many simply aren’t saving enough and are walking into retirement poverty.

“For employers, the combination of better governance and financial education could be a real game changer in driving better employee behaviours and ownership of their retirement planning. In addition to this, we’re focused on the growing demand from all stakeholders for ‘greener’ and responsible pension investment as part of an effective pension strategy.”

1.      Introducing data-driven governance

Gregson says a data-driven approach to pension governance could radically improve member outcomes and increase engagement with workplace pensions.

He adds that pension governance often falls short because it only focuses on whether the plan as a whole is performing well and if charges are competitive, but it doesn’t analyse whether each employee is tracking towards their own retirement outcome and taking appropriate actions, be that changing their investments or contribution levels, for example.

Gregson says, “We need to move away from governing at scheme level, to governing at an individual level and use data to determine what actions we need to encourage employees to take. Helping employees create a personal retirement goal and then monitoring where they are against that ambition, may be the only way to put the right communications strategies in place and effectively engage the members – personalisation is key.”

2.      Are your pensions green enough?

Recent research from pension provider Cushon[i] found that people are increasingly concerned about the impact their pensions are having on issues such as climate change. It reported that two thirds are concerned that their workplace pension could be investing in businesses that are contributing to the climate crisis, while 88 per cent of employees want their employer to take action to address this such as by moving to an environmentally-friendly pension provider.

The report also highlighted that the average UK pension pot unwittingly finances an average of 23 tonnes of CO2 emissions every year through the businesses it invests in.

Matthew Gregson said, “The upcoming UN Climate Change conference (COP26) will accelerate action towards the goals of the Paris Agreement and the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change and increase pressure on companies to take action on the climate crisis. The question is how investors will play their role in holding them to account.

“Workplace pensions are no longer solely about accumulating a fund to live comfortably in retirement – they form part of company culture and decision-making around ethical issues, which are increasingly important to employees. In addition to ensuring their provider and default fund have an appropriate ESG focus, governance committees can look at the voting records of fund managers to really ensure they are acting in-line with those ambitions. We believe this will drive engagement, especially for the generation coming into the workplace.”

3.      Better Financial education

Employees have experienced financial challenges due to the pandemic and more than ever need support from employers, both for today and keeping one eye on their futures.

According to a survey from Wealth at Work, 41% of organisations are still failing to offer employees any support to better manage their money, even though more than half (51%) of those surveyed said the pandemic had made them conscious of the need to save more, with more than a quarter realising their current savings were inadequate.

Gregson said, “The truth for UK workplace pensions is that we’ve shifted more of the onus for their retirement outcome onto employees. As such, the most affordable and important step employers (and governance committees) can take is in improving financial literacy and engagement with finances, especially retirement planning.

Combined with effective, data-driven governance, companies should be building a clear picture of their employees’ financial needs and concerns and tailoring the pensions and broader financial education and guidance they receive to help employees build better habits around their money. And this should be at an individual level – which may sound difficult to achieve, but, with the right data, it can take little effort to sign post employees to the things they should be focussing on and the resources they can access to support them.”