Brands are losing the battle for attention: Here’s how they can up their game
Written by Julia Payne, founder of Fractional CMO Services.
Despite generating more online content than ever, brands are still struggling to capture and convert attention. Messaging is reaching screens – with platforms like YouTube now frequented by 94% of adult internet users, according to Ofcom – but not always the audiences behind them.
More noise, less notice
The issue is fatigue and a lack of real-world connection with marketing output. Gartner has reported that 81% of consumers seeing ads on socials actively tune them out, 64% finding them “annoying” or “intrusive” and 75% feeling “bombarded”, according to HubSpot and Accenture, respectively.
Gen-Zers in particular are so tired of being sold to that they’ll typically scroll past anything corporate or polished, 72% preferring peer recommendations to direct advertising according to Brandwatch. The reason? Intentions feel more trustworthy and honest.
Engaging a disengaged audience
So, how can teams tasked with capturing and converting genuine online interest respond? With relevance, reciprocity, authenticity, consistency and co-ordination.
1) Relevance: Tesco Value
Tesco’s 2025 back-to-school print campaign wasn’t just selling utility in linking adjustable uniform hems to parental pride. It was capitalising on emotion. Ranked in Kantar’s top 3% of UK campaigns for brand affinity and top 9% for customer relevance, it took customers on a journey they could feel, translating first-day nerves into family memories to position itself as the solution. It was this closeness to real lives – the relevance captured – that made the ads a success.
Online relevance
Of course, generating relevance online can prove more challenging. People often turn to social media to escape their problems, many disillusioned by low prosperity and the cost-of-living crisis. This makes them less receptive to direct purchase messaging. They want to be met with real human value beyond that of the products and services offered, regardless of how relatably these are presented.
2) Reciprocity: Real-world people
It’s only by approaching prospects on their level, person to person rather than brand to consumer – top down – that organisations can break through that wall.
Despite operating in virtual spaces, viewers are still real people who demand empathy, ethical alignment, laughter, and inclusion in exchange for their attention. They need to see that brands have invested in them – through understanding, regular engagement, and the creation of spaces where their voices are welcomed – before they’re willing to make an investment in kind. Because attention nowadays is reciprocal, not one sided.
3) Authenticity: Taking off with the truth
Ryanair delivers this type of value particularly well. Most airlines would hide the fact that there’s no window in row 11, but this budget brand invites people to laugh about it. Rather than masking limitations, it turns them into part of the story.
This honesty reinforces its no-frills positioning and strengthens trust among the brand’s 2.7 million international followers, who increasingly expect transparency over polish. Much like Tesco’s back-to-school campaign, the success lies not in creative spectacle but in recognisable reality. When messaging reflects lived experience, people pay attention because they recognise themselves in it. Authenticity pays dividends in an attention economy shaped by scepticism, serving as a signal of credibility to audiences tired of being misled.
4) Consistency and coordination: Deliberate strategy
As Ryanair has shown, message delivery matters just as much as content. Tone, timing, and channel behaviour must confirm expectations rather than challenge them. This is where many organisations fall short.
The same is true in a B2B context. Marketing, sales, and customer success teams often operate against different metrics, timelines, and interpretations of audience needs, producing fragmented experiences that inadvertently erode trust. Aligning teams around shared data, definitions of success, and a unified commercial narrative, by contrast – often through Revenue Operations or RevOps approaches – allows organisations to present a coherent story across the customer journey. Messaging no longer shifts between campaigns and conversations, delivery no longer diverges from promises, and trust becomes deliberate and repeatable rather than accidental when people work together.
This confidence quickly translates into steady revenue, with the IPA and Financial Times showing trust is capable of directly influencing profit, acquisition, brand strength, and long-term performance.
Attention forms before brands realise it
Co-ordination has become even more important as buying journeys move further outside the visible funnel. Dreamdata reports that the average B2B purchase now takes 211 days to complete across 76 touchpoints and nearly 7 stakeholders. Much of the trust required to progress these journeys forms before organisations know prospects exist, shaped by peer commentary, independent analysis, and increasingly, AI-generated summaries.
As such, brands cannot rely on campaigns alone to influence perception. They must establish clear positioning early, so that when audiences encounter them later, the narrative already feels familiar and credible. Attention rarely begins where marketers expect it to, which is why strategic collaboration matters.
Consistent presence, not constant output
This synchronisation must be sustained over time, with brands urged to remember that consistency must not be confused with constant activity, which simply overwhelms.
Generative platforms have made it easier than ever for businesses to produce content at scale, accelerating the risk of fatigue. Indeed, research from eMarketer suggests that excessive exposure to brand content pushes up to 60% of audiences to disengage entirely.
Rather than chasing short-term visibility, B2B and B2C brands alike must prioritise the qualities that make them stand out longer-term in a world of computerised messaging: honesty, sharper positioning, stronger values alignment, and steady, recognisable presence. This is what earns lasting attention.