Most-Clicked Video Ads Can Deliver Lower Returns, Study of 88,000 Meta Ads Finds

person holding black samsung android smartphone

Businesses focusing heavily on clicks and views when measuring the success of social media advertising could be overlooking the metrics that matter most to their bottom line, according to new analysis of more than 88,000 Meta video ads.

Research from user-generated content marketplace Billo found a significant disconnect between the adverts attracting the most attention and those generating the strongest financial returns.

The study analysed 88,329 sales-focused Meta video advertisements running between January and June 2026, covering $122 million in advertising spend and $212 million in purchase value.

Among the 14 product categories examined, Health & Beauty achieved the highest click-through rate (CTR) at 2.36%, yet recorded a return on ad spend (ROAS) of just 1.82.

By contrast, Baby & Toddler advertising had the lowest CTR at 1.37%, but generated the highest ROAS in the study at 4.99.

That means the category attracting the most clicks produced a ROAS around 63% lower than the category generating the fewest clicks, according to Billo’s analysis.

The findings could be particularly relevant to businesses finalising their advertising strategies ahead of Black Friday and the crucial fourth-quarter trading period.

Clicks Do Not Necessarily Equal Sales

Donatas Smailys, co-founder and CEO of Billo, said:

“Most teams are measured on attention, because it moves fast and looks like progress. But attention and return are not the same thing, and in this data, they often move in opposite directions.

“The ads that got the most clicks often returned the least. The ones that got the fewest clicks often returned the most. If you optimize for the number that’s easiest to move, you can end up scaling the ads that cost you the most.”

Health & Beauty advertising also performed strongly when measured by its ability to initially capture viewers’ attention.

The category recorded a 28.11% hook rate – defined in the research as the proportion of viewers who continued watching beyond the first three seconds – placing it third among the 14 categories.

However, its ROAS ranked only 11th.

Baby & Toddler advertising showed almost the opposite pattern. Its 22.56% hook rate ranked 12th and its CTR was last, yet its ROAS of 4.99 comfortably led the categories analysed.

The return was around 2.7 times that of Health & Beauty despite its substantially lower click-through rate.

High Engagement Does Not Guarantee High ROAS

The discrepancy was not limited to those two sectors.

Toys & Games achieved the highest hook rate in the study at 28.79% and the fourth-highest CTR at 1.89%. Despite those apparently strong engagement figures, its ROAS was only 1.62, ranking 12th.

Electronics presented another striking contrast. It recorded the second-lowest hook rate, at 22.21%, but delivered the second-highest ROAS at 3.44.

The cross-industry averages were a CTR of 1.93%, hook rate of 25.44% and ROAS of 2.17.

How The 14 Categories Compared

Category CTR Hook Rate ROAS
Health & Beauty 2.36% (1) 28.11% (3) 1.82 (11)
Arts & Entertainment 2.15% (2) 23.02% (9) 2.04 (8)
Home & Garden 2.09% (3) 25.06% (6) 2.83 (3)
Toys & Games 1.89% (4) 28.79% (1) 1.62 (12)
Food & Beverages 1.84% (5) 26.14% (5) 2.51 (4)
Services 1.80% (6) 23.86% (7) 2.27 (7)
Apparel & Accessories 1.77% (7) 22.94% (10) 2.46 (6)
Electronics 1.68% (8) 22.21% (13) 3.44 (2)
Software 1.61% (9) 22.90% (11) 1.04 (14)
Other 1.58% (10) 23.59% (8) 2.48 (5)
Animals & Pet Supplies 1.54% (11) 21.32% (14) 1.05 (13)
Business & Industrial 1.52% (12) 28.74% (2) 1.84 (10)
Sporting Goods 1.44% (13) 26.89% (4) 2.02 (9)
Baby & Toddler 1.37% (14) 22.56% (12) 4.99 (1)
Cross-industry average 1.93% 25.44% 2.17

Are Businesses Targeting The Wrong Advertising Metrics?

The results raise questions about how businesses assess advertising performance, particularly when engagement measures such as clicks, views and watch rates can provide almost immediate feedback.

A campaign that generates fewer clicks could still prove more commercially successful if those clicks come from consumers with a stronger intention to buy.

Smailys said:

“Just because people don’t stop to watch an ad doesn’t mean they won’t buy, and vice versa.

“An ad that appeals to everyone pulls in a lot of people who were never going to buy. A narrower ad might get fewer views, but it reaches people who actually want to buy.

“With Q4 budgets about to lock in behind whatever targets brands set today, treating hooks as a filter rather than a goal matters more than ever.”

The analysis suggests businesses should also be cautious about benchmarking their campaigns against broad advertising averages.

ROAS varied considerably between sectors, ranging from 1.04 for Software advertising to 4.99 for Baby & Toddler – meaning what constitutes strong performance in one market may be very different in another.

For marketing teams, this could mean using CTR and hook rates primarily as indicators of how audiences are responding to creative content, rather than treating either metric as definitive evidence that a campaign is commercially successful.

Ultimately, purchase value and return on advertising expenditure may provide a clearer indication of whether advertising is contributing to the company’s wider commercial objectives.

About The Research

Billo’s analysis covered 88,329 sales-objective Meta video advertisements that ran between January and June 2026, with each advertisement generating more than 1,000 impressions.

The dataset represented $122 million in advertising expenditure and $212 million in purchase value across 14 categories based on advertiser product type.

ROAS was calculated by dividing the purchase value generated by each advertisement by its advertising spend before averaging the results across advertisements within each category.

The findings therefore represent Billo’s analysis of the advertising dataset rather than evidence that higher click-through rates inherently cause lower financial returns.