Innovating Against Counterfeiters: The Power of Intellectual Property in Cash Security
The cash industry isn’t as static as it might seem. It’s a constant battle against sophisticated counterfeiting, which demands ongoing technological advancement and major investment in research and development. This leads to banknotes packed with complex technologies, which rely heavily on intellectual property to safeguard economic systems.
While digital payments are taking off and cybercrime is all over the news, cash remains a critical way to settle transactions—and a big draw for criminals. The challenge of counterfeiting is a persistent and growing problem for currency systems. Counterfeiters, often well-funded, use increasingly advanced methods, including high-tech printing, scanning, and digital forgery. This is a reality even in the most technologically advanced countries, like the United States: “The threat of counterfeit U.S. currency to the financial system of the United States continues to evolve. Advances in technology, the availability of scanning and printing devices and the adoption of the U.S. dollar by nations as their legal tender have exacerbated the global threat,” says the U.S. Secret Service.
Despite the risks, criminals continue to believe that counterfeiting is simply easier to make money than through legitimate means – and in some cases, they have become so brazen that they have even established regular business hours. A recent example is a Naples clan linked to the Camorra mafia, who operated their counterfeiting enterprise on a standard weekday schedule, from 9:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m., and until 1:00 p.m. on Sundays. However, counterfeiters’ success is generally short-lived as the relentless pressure compels the cash industry to maintain its position at the forefront of technological innovation, developing increasingly robust and intricate security features to counteract these evolving threats. These innovations rely not only on scientific methods but also on intellectual property protection, ensuring that counterfeiters cannot produce a flawless imitation.
How intellectual property guards us against counterfeiters
Banknote technology has come a long way, with modern bills integrated with state-of-the-art components. The modern banknote uses a mix of optical, chemical, and physical security features, such as high-tech holograms, detailed watermarks, and special inks, all built for solid authentication. The constant improvements to these features, along with better substrate materials, keep physical currency secure in our digital world and make it easy for people to spot a fake, assures Jane Raymond, Professor of Visual Cognition at the University of Birmingham in the UK. Her team conducted a public perception study of micro-optic security features designed by the U.S. banknote solutions company Crane Currency, and discovered that the public could discern fake banknotes in a third of second if the security feature included 3D: “The results were super clean, even in low light situations. The research shows the real potential of modern 3D technologies to reduce the circulation of counterfeit banknotes.”
Innovation, however, can backfire if those technological advances aren’t properly protected – and that’s where intellectual property comes in to guard advancements and keep them out of the wrong hands. Patents defend the unique technologies and processes used in making banknotes, while trademarks secure the distinct visual elements that help with authentication. In a highly competitive field like security printing, they’re not just important, but absolutely essential for proper protection, says Thomas Savare, CEO of French security printer Oberthur Fiduciaire: “We must innovate to ensure that we are always one or more steps ahead of the counterfeiters… I believe that intellectual property will be at the heart of the fiduciary sector of tomorrow and the day after tomorrow, since it is already important, and it will continue to grow.”
The effectiveness of intellectual property protection is perfectly illustrated by the discovery of ‘the most sophisticated fakes ever found in the EU’ by the Spanish National Police and the Police of Catalonia in 2022. The advanced design and high quality of these forgeries made them the most dangerous counterfeits produced in the EU in recent years. However, what connected the fakes to the same suspect was their similarity to counterfeits from 2009. Basically, the criminals couldn’t get their hands on the latest security printing technologies and were forced to use outdated security features. This helped both the public and the police identify the counterfeiters.
Cooperation enhances security further
Intellectual property protection isn’t just a business move; it’s the foundation of secure currency systems, which involve customers like central banks, banknote manufacturers, their suppliers, and professional cash handlers. And for the whole ecosystem to run smoothly, participants tend to share their knowledge and make their patented technologies available to other authorized players. Take Oberthur Fiduciaire’s Bioguard solution, for example, which protects banknotes against viruses, bacteria, and fungi. Developed after the H1N1 crisis in the early 2000s, it has been constantly improved to the point of being highly effective against COVID-19, which has been confirmed by independent labs. Even though it’s heavily protected and patented, it’s now used on billions of banknotes worldwide thanks to a flexible patent system that lets many industry players use it at a low cost.
The current trend of global interconnectedness and open borders, where people naturally bring currency to other countries, further increases the need for all participants in the system to interact – and for cash to be better protected from criminals, says Kevin McKenna, CEO of American banknote authentication solutions company Authentix: “As the global economy becomes more interconnected, there may be efforts to standardize security features across different currencies to facilitate easier verification and reduce fraud on an international scale.” This situation creates a dual challenge for the industry: they must block unauthorized access to the newest technical developments to fight counterfeiting, but they also need to ensure effective collaboration and information sharing.
Sharing products can help, but this doesn’t solve all the challenges the industry is facing today. Building on this trend of collaboration, another viable option is acquiring exclusive rights to another company’s intellectual property. This approach allows for the creation of a more comprehensive product by leveraging the expertise of multiple developers. A prime example is Oberthur Fiduciaire’s acquisition of a 71% stake in Rolling Optics, a Swedish micro-optic technology company, to enhance its production capabilities and drive technological advancements in the industry. This cooperation resulted in Anima™, a micro-optical thread that provides instant recognition using dynamic features like those tested by Jane Raymond, enabling rapid authentication without additional tools. Their colleagues, Crane Currency, did the same: they acquired its Motion security thread technology from Nanoventions firm several years ago, a move that proved to be successful: “What makes Motion family of security features so difficult to counterfeit is the use of proprietary materials and processes. Thus, the would-be counterfeiter has no commercially available starting point from which to attempt simulation, explains Crane Currency.
Efforts like these create a complex network of security measures, constantly improved through research and development, ensuring physical currency remains secure and reliable. By protecting their technological advances, cash printers build a strong defense against counterfeiters, forcing them to deal with constantly evolving and increasingly complex security. Furthermore, the willingness of cash printing companies to collaborate with authorized partners helps build a robust security ecosystem and keeps cash trustworthy in a world that’s increasingly complex and technology driven.