Beating the tariffs: How can businesses continue to move towards efficiency and growth?
Ian Nicholls, CEO of Explic8, tackles the issue of tariffs and how businesses can best respond to the current crisis
The whole world is talking about tariffs. Stock markets are crashing, suffering the biggest losses for years, investments and pensions are being devalued. Prices are rising. Products are being boycotted. Sales are falling. Profits are plummeting and forecasters are saying this is not a blip because recovery may take years.
Globally, countries and companies alike are looking for solutions.
One course of action is to accept the tariffs. Or retaliate and impose your own tariffs. Another course of action is to negotiate better more affordable exchange agreements. Another is to move.
What if there was a way to allow your organisation to continue business as usual and focus on efficiency and growth?
This article outlines a better way to be a tariff buster.
The introduction of tariffs by the US is having significant effects on the global market:
- Market Volatility: Tariffs led to increased volatility in stock markets, similar to the reactions seen during major crashes. Traders often reacted sharply to news about tariffs, leading to rapid price changes.
- Investor Sentiment: Just as during historical crashes, investor sentiment played a crucial role. Uncertainty from tariff announcements caused fluctuations in consumer and business confidence, impacting stock prices.
- Increased Prices: Tariffs raise the cost of imported goods, leading to higher prices for consumers and businesses that rely on these products.
- Trade Tensions: Tariffs can prompt retaliatory measures from affected countries, resulting in trade wars that disrupt global supply chains.
- Shifts in Trade Patterns: Countries may seek alternative markets or suppliers, altering traditional trade relationships and promoting regional trade agreements.
- Impact on Domestic Producers: While some domestic industries may benefit from reduced competition, others that rely on imported materials may face higher production costs.
- Economic Uncertainty: Tariffs can create uncertainty in the global market, leading to reduced investment and slower economic growth.
- Global Supply Chain Disruption: Increased costs and trade barriers can disrupt established supply chains, affecting production efficiency and delivery times.
- Inflationary Pressures: Higher costs for imported goods can contribute to inflation, impacting overall economic stability.
- Customer Dissatisfaction: Can arise from unmet expectations, poor product quality, unsatisfactory customer service and higher prices.
The mantra to “Make America Great Again” is a drive to return manufacturing to the US instead of outsourcing to cheaper overseas locations and with it to bring jobs and prosperity to the country.
However, moving manufacturing from one country to another is a costly and time-consuming business involving several critical factors:
- Strategic Planning
- Market Analysis: Evaluate market potential in the new location.
- Cost-Benefit Analysis: Assess costs related to manufacturing, labour, logistics, and tariffs.
- R&D
- Technology Transfer: Plan for transferring technology and knowledge to the new site.
- Local Adaptation: Adapt products for local market preferences and regulations.
- Collaboration with Local Institutions: Engage with local universities or research institutions for innovation and support.
- HR
- Workforce Analysis: Assess the availability of skilled labour in the new location.
- Recruitment Strategy: Develop a plan for hiring local talent, including training programs.
- Cultural Integration: Prepare for cultural differences and integrate teams effectively.
- Employee Transition Plans: Consider relocation for key personnel and manage communication with existing employees.
- Regulatory Affairs
- Compliance Research: Understand local regulations, industry standards, and compliance requirements.
- Permits and Licences: Obtain necessary permits and licences for manufacturing operations.
- Environmental Regulations: Comply with local environmental laws and sustainability practices.
- Supply Chain Management
- Supplier Assessment: Identify and evaluate local suppliers for materials and components.
- Logistics Planning: Develop efficient logistics and distribution strategies in the new location.
- Stock Build
- Capacity Management: Increased output before planned plant closure to build sufficient stock to satisfy the market until the new facility begins production.
- Facility Setup
- Site Selection: Choose an appropriate location based on infrastructure, proximity to suppliers, and costs.
- Facility Design: Plan the layout of the manufacturing facility to optimise workflow and efficiency.
- Implementation
- Pilot Production: Start with a pilot run to test processes and systems.
- Quality Control Systems: Establish quality assurance protocols to maintain product standards.
- Monitoring and Adjustment
- Performance Metrics: Track performance against goals and benchmarks.
- Continuous Improvement: Be prepared to make adjustments based on feedback and operational data.
- Stakeholder Communication
- Internal Communication: Keep all stakeholders informed throughout the transition.
- External Communication: Manage public relations and community engagement in the new location.
Critical decisions lie around:
- Do we move manufacturing facilities or create duplicates?
- Do we transfer our trained experienced staff or hire in the new location?
- How much stock do we need to cover the transition and how long will it take to build the stock?
By carefully addressing these considerations, companies can effectively transition their manufacturing operations to a new country while minimising disruption and maximising efficiency.
But there is another way.
The pie chart below represents a typical cost breakdown for manufactured goods.
Figure 1: Cost Breakdown
If your product costs $100 and gets hit with a 25% tariff, it goes to market, costing the customer $125.
If an organisation could reduce its material costs by 20% and its direct labour costs by 10% it should also reduce the manufacturing overhead and would have the effect of reducing the product cost to $87.50 (a 12.5% reduction in overall manufacturing costs) and with the imposition of a 25% tariff, the product would reach the market at $109.38. Not too bad an increase given inflation rates these days.
Why stop there? if your organisation could reduce overall manufacturing cost by 20% and bring the product cost to $80, the 25% tariff would leave the product on the market at $100!
This approach eliminates the need for moving from one country to another and eliminates the involvement in trade negotiations and deal brokering.
It allows your organisation to continue business as usual and focus on efficiency and growth.
So, how do we reduce the overall manufacturing cost by 20%?
In the example below, the costs of R&D, Shipping and Distribution and Sales and Marketing remain the same. Material costs are down 25%, labour costs down 20% packaging cost down 20%, manufacturing overhead down by 60% and administrative costs down by 25%. The percentages sound big but we’re only shaving a dollar here and a dollar there off the cost per unit.
The combined effect of these changes achieves a 21.5% reduction in the overall manufacturing cost bringing the product cost down to $78.5 which with a 25% tariff will hit the market at $98.13 – even less than before the tariff.
| Item | Before | After | % Reduction |
| Research and Development (R&D) | $5.00 | $5.00 | 0.00% |
| Direct Materials | $42.00 | $31.50 | 25.00% |
| Direct Labour | $21.00 | $16.80 | 20.00% |
| Packaging Costs | $5.00 | $4.00 | 20.00% |
| Shipping and Distribution | $7.00 | $7.00 | 0.00% |
| Manufacturing Overhead | $8.00 | $3.20 | 60.00% |
| Administrative Expenses | $4.00 | $3.00 | 25.00% |
| Sales and Marketing Expenses | $8.00 | $8.00 | 0.00% |
| Totals | $100.00 | $78.50 | 21.50% |
Figure 2: Cost Reduction Table
Figure 3: Cost Reduction Chart
All of these reductions are achievable and there are tools and techniques available to implement even greater cost reductions.
So, how do we do it?
An excellent method for achieving significant savings in direct materials consumed during the manufacture of a product is by going “back to basics” and conducting a Cost of Quality (CoQ) analysis using the CoQ process to identify where the opportunities are. While the specific amount saved can vary widely depending on the industry, product type, and existing quality issues, studies suggest that companies can often save between 5% to 30% of their direct material costs through improved quality practices.
These savings can result from:
- Reduction in Scrap and Rework: Identifying and addressing quality issues can minimise waste.
- Improved Process Efficiency: Streamlining production processes can reduce material usage.
- Improved manufacturing scheduling: Improved sequencing and scheduling can reduce material usage.
- Enhanced Supplier Quality: Working with suppliers to improve material quality can lower defects and waste.
- Better Design Practices: Designing products for manufacturability can reduce material consumption.
Overall, a CoQ analysis helps identify areas for improvement, which can lead to more efficient use of materials and lower costs.
Reducing Costs
Reducing labour costs in manufacturing can be achieved through several best practice approaches:
- Lean Manufacturing: Implement lean principles to eliminate waste, optimise workflows, and improve productivity. Focussing on continuous improvement and value stream mapping.
- Process Optimisation: Regularly review and optimise manufacturing processes to identify bottlenecks and improve throughput without additional labour.
- Employee Engagement: Foster a positive work culture that encourages employee engagement and productivity, which can lead to lower turnover rates and associated training costs.
- Employee Training and Development: Provide training to enhance employee skills, which can lead to increased efficiency and reduced errors. Cross-training employees can also enhance flexibility in workforce deployment.
- Invest in Ergonomics: Improve workplace ergonomics to reduce strain and injury, leading to decreased absenteeism and lower healthcare costs.
- Flexible Workforce: Use a flexible workforce model that allows for scaling labour up or down based on demand, reducing costs during slower periods.
- Shift Scheduling: Optimise shift schedules to align with production demands, minimising overtime and ensuring efficient use of labour resources.
- Contract Labour: Consider outsourcing non-core functions or using contract labour for peak times to manage labour costs effectively.
- Automation and Technology: Invest in automation technologies such as robotics and AI to streamline processes, reduce manual labour, and increase efficiency.
- Performance Metrics: Establish clear performance metrics to track productivity and identify areas where labour costs can be reduced without compromising quality.
By implementing these strategies, manufacturers can effectively reduce labour costs while maintaining or improving product quality and operational efficiency.
Greater Efficiency + Higher Quality + Lower Costs = GROWTH
About the author
Ian Nicholls is CEO of Explic8