What Gets Leaders Promoted Isn’t What Employees Want, New Global Study Finds

20260409_GLES-Promotion_LinkedIn-1

New global research from Hogan Assessments finds that the characteristics and behaviours most frequently displayed by executives do not match the qualities employees say they want from leaders, revealing a significant gap in how organizations identify and reward leadership.

“Organizations have long tended to reward visibility, confidence, and ambition in leaders,” said Allison Howell, CEO of Hogan Assessments. “But employees are telling us they want something more fundamental: leaders they can trust, leaders who communicate clearly, and leaders who create the conditions for teams to succeed.”

The report, The Leadership Divide: Global Insights on Who Leads vs. Who Should, compares personality assessment data from more than 21,000 executives in Hogan’s global database with survey responses from 9,794 full-time employees across 25 markets, including the United States, Brazil, Mexico, Germany, and France.

A Clear Misalignment Between What Organizations Reward and What Employees Value

One of the most striking findings is that there is zero overlap between the top five competencies, most commonly demonstrated by executives and the five characteristics employees say they want from leaders.

Globally, executives tend to stand out for inspiring others, competing with peers, presenting ideas publicly, taking initiative, and driving innovation. Employees, by contrast, place the highest value on communication, integrity, accountability, sound decision-making, and the ability to lead effectively.

What Employees Say Matters Most

Across markets, employee responses showed strong alignment around the foundations of effective leadership. Nearly 97% of respondents worldwide identified communication and trust-related characteristics, including integrity, accountability, and sound decision-making, as essential for leadership success.

In the UK, employees place particular importance on diplomacy, tact, and sensitivity in communication (73%), strategic thinking and curiosity (63%), and drive, energy, and goal orientation (60%). Together, these responses suggest that UK employees value leaders who pair thoughtful communication with strategic focus and strong motivation.

UK employees also value leaders who foster connection and create a more engaging work environment. Respondents most often identify teamwork and a sense of belonging (40%), fun, variety, and enjoyment of work (32%), data-driven decision-making (30%), and achievement and influence (30%) as important motivators. These preferences point to a desire for leaders who combine evidence-informed judgment with collaboration and an environment people want to be part of.

The research also identifies behaviors employees believe weaken leadership effectiveness. Globally, emotional volatility and unpredictability (72%), passive aggression (62%), arrogance and entitlement (59%), and extreme caution (56%) were identified as behaviors that erode trust, increase disengagement, and weaken team performance. Confidence is one of the clearest illustrations of the divide between what gets leaders noticed and what makes them effective: the same assertiveness and self-assurance that can help leaders advance may, when overused, be experienced by teams as arrogance

In the UK, respondents expressed particularly strong concern about emotional volatility and unpredictability (77%), arrogance and entitlement (72%), passive aggression and stubborn resistance (60%), and excessive caution (50%). UK leaders are often confident, independent, and willing to push boundaries, but may also question motives, remain privately skeptical, or present a cooperative front while resisting behind the scenes. Employee ratings suggest a particularly strong preference for leaders who are transparent, steady, and consistent in follow-through.

What the Findings Suggest for Leaders and Organizations

The findings suggest many organizations may still be rewarding leadership emergence over leadership effectiveness. Too often, the behaviors that help individuals gain visibility and get promoted are not the same behaviors that build trust, strengthen teams, or support sustained performance once in the role.

In the UK, leadership styles tend to emphasize autonomy, flexibility, experimentation, and intuition-based judgment, while employees place greater value on tactful communication, team connection, data-informed decisions, and transparency. Organizations looking to close that gap should embed those qualities into how leaders are identified, developed, and evaluated, with coaching, feedback, and performance systems that reward accountability, open communication, and follow-through.

UK leaders already bring meaningful strengths: ambition, curiosity, cooperation, flexibility, and openness to experimentation. The opportunity lies in building on those strengths while strengthening team connection and evidence-informed decision-making, and ensuring that the independence and confidence that help leaders advance are matched by the transparency and consistency employees want.

“Leadership pipelines are strongest when organizations align how they identify and develop leaders with what employees actually value,” said Howell. “These findings show that trust, accountability, and sound judgment are not secondary qualities. They are central to team effectiveness and long-term performance.”

About the Report

The full report, The Leadership Divide: Global Insights on Who Leads vs. Who Should, explores these findings in greater detail and offers guidance for organizations seeking to strengthen leadership development.