Amy-Spooner-VerriBerri

Written by Amy Spooner, VerriBerri

AI has changed marketing, there is no question about that. It can help marketers research faster, analyse data, identify trends, generate ideas and even produce content in a fraction of the time it once took. Used well, AI is an incredibly powerful tool. However, there is a stark difference between making marketing faster and making it better.

As AI becomes increasingly embedded in marketing, I firmly believe the human element is becoming more important, not less. When anyone can generate a blog, write a social post or create a campaign in seconds, the challenge is no longer simply producing content, but creating something that makes people stop, feel a connection and therefore, remember a brand.

Everyone can create content, so what makes yours different?

The biggest change AI has brought to marketing is accessibility. Businesses of all sizes can now produce content quickly and cheaply. But when everyone has access to the same tools, the tools themselves stop being the differentiator.

We are already seeing this visually. If you scroll through social media, you’re likely to notice the same styles of graphics and AI-generated visuals appearing over and over. They may look polished to some, but they can also feel interchangeable. The same applies to written content: technically correct, well-structured and even optimised, but lacking that personality.

There is an even bigger problem when businesses rely on AI without a clear brand identity behind it. Does that social post actually look and sound like that business? Does it reflect its personality or communicate what makes it different?

AI can produce an image or article in seconds, but it doesn’t necessarily understand why a particular colour matters to a brand, why a certain tone of voice has been deliberately chosen, or what will make a customer remember one business over another.

The result can be marketing that is technically polished but completely forgettable. And in a world already saturated with content, forgettable is most certainly a problem. Good marketing has always been connected with understanding people: what they need, what they value, what makes them trust a brand and, ultimately, what makes them care.

Human expertise still matters

This is where experienced marketers have an important role to play. AI can identify what people are searching for, but it doesn’t sit down with a client and understand why they started their business. It can’t get to know the people behind a brand, understand their ambitions or recognise the small personal nuances that make them genuinely different from their competitors. It also can’t bring the judgement that comes from years of experience.

In my experience, sometimes the best marketing decision isn’t the one that produces the most content, but actually knowing what not to say, which idea to pursue in line with upcoming business plans, which audience to prioritise, or when something really just doesn’t sound like the business it represents.

I believe that AI should be used to support our work and make processes more efficient, but it shouldn’t replace the relationships built with clients. Understanding a business takes in-person conversations and a genuine understanding of where that business wants to go and why.

More content doesn’t equal better marketing

Google’s own guidance follows this shift, warning against scaled content created primarily to manipulate search rankings, including the use of AI to produce large amounts of content without adding actual value for users.

With this, the issue isn’t whether AI is being used, but whether the content is useful and created for people instead of being produced at scale to try and influence search rankings. For marketers, that should be a useful reminder: AI can help us create more, but creating more isn’t the same as communicating better.

Marketing isn’t a luxury in the age of AI

There is a wider misconception that if AI has made content production faster and cheaper, businesses can reduce their investment in marketing. However, as we’ve established, producing more content isn’t always effective marketing.

When the barriers to creating campaign elements are lower, the value increasingly lies in knowing what to create, why you’re creating it and who you’re creating it for. Without that strategy piece, it is easy to end up producing content just because you can.

Besides, marketing shouldn’t be seen as just the production of content. Fundamentally, it’s understanding an audience, building a recognisable brand, finding opportunities and making sure every piece of communication supports the wider business goals. Those decisions still require experience and of course, a level of judgement.

The businesses that strive in this era will be those that combine technology with creativity, strategy, personality and a genuine understanding of their customers.

As AI develops, the more human marketing matters

I don’t believe the future of marketing is choosing between AI and people, but actually how both can be used intelligently. AI can help marketers research, analyse and become more efficient with those time-consuming tasks.

But it can’t replace the human understanding, creativity and judgement needed to build a genuine connection with an audience.

—

About the author